KAI vs. KAI: A Trademark Dispute Over Two Fashion Brands

The dispute between Kai Collective and Kai Trump's clothing venture raises important questions about trademark priority, unregistered rights, and the protection of fashion brands in international markets.
Background to the Dispute
A trademark dispute has emerged in the United States between Kai Collective Limited, a London-based fashion company, and KMT Ventures LLC, the company behind Kai Trump's clothing venture.
In September 2025, Kai Trump, granddaughter of U.S. President Donald Trump, publicly launched a clothing collection featuring branded apparel. On October 7, 2025, KMT Ventures filed a U.S. trademark application for KAI, covering various clothing products, including sweatshirts, T-shirts, skirts, shorts, hats and footwear. The application also included certain entertainment and educational services.
However, Kai Collective claims it has been using KAI commercially in the United States for several years. Founded by Nigerian entrepreneur Fisayo Longe, Kai Collective is a fashion business known for its contemporary womenswear. Although established in the United Kingdom, the company maintains that it has sold and shipped clothing bearing the KAI mark to customers in the United States since at least April 23, 2021.
On February 2, 2026, Kai Collective filed its own U.S. trademark application for KAI. The USPTO subsequently suspended that application because of KMT Ventures' earlier-filed application. The competing applications ultimately led Kai Collective to commence formal opposition proceedings before the United States Patent and Trademark Office's Trademark Trial and Appeal Board (TTAB).
How the Proceedings Have Developed
The USPTO published KMT Ventures' application for opposition on March 24, 2026. Following two extensions of the opposition period, Kai Collective filed its Notice of Opposition on July 22, 2026, challenging registration of KAI for all goods in International Class 25.
The opposition, filed under Section 2(d) of the Lanham Act, rests on two principal arguments:
that Kai Collective possesses earlier trademark rights in KAI through commercial use, and
that registration of the identical mark for overlapping clothing products would create a likelihood of consumer confusion.
The proceeding subsequently took an important procedural turn. KMT Ventures was required to answer the opposition by September 20, 2026. On October 1, 2026, the TTAB issued a Notice of Default after finding that no answer or request for a further extension appeared to have been filed. The Board suspended proceedings and allowed KMT Ventures 30 days to show cause why default judgment should not be entered.
As of November 11, 2026, the publicly available prosecution history reviewed for Opposition No. 91309041 contains no subsequent response or final judgment. Accordingly, the opposition has not been shown to have resulted in a final determination.
The Legal Considerations
Trademark Priority: Does Earlier Use Prevail Over Earlier Registration?
One of the central questions is whether Kai Collective can establish trademark rights that predate KMT Ventures' October 2025 application. Under U.S. trademark law, rights may arise through qualifying commercial use, even without federal registration. Consequently, an earlier-filed application does not necessarily defeat a business that can establish prior rights in the same or a confusingly similar mark.
Section 7(c) of the Lanham Act, 15 U.S.C. § 1057(c), also provides that an application which ultimately matures into registration may confer constructive-use priority from its filing date, subject to qualifying earlier rights.
Kai Collective alleges that its use of KAI in U.S. commerce began in April 2021 and has continued substantially uninterrupted. If established, that use could support a claim of priority over KMT Ventures' later application. However, the claimed date alone is insufficient. Kai Collective would need to substantiate its assertion with evidence demonstrating qualifying trademark use in the United States.
There is also a distinction between the filing basis of KMT Ventures' application and any independently established earlier trademark rights. Although the application was filed on an intent-to-use basis, that fact does not necessarily resolve whether the applicant could establish relevant commercial use before filing.
Unregistered Trademarks and the Evidence of Commercial Use
Kai Collective's opposition illustrates the significance of unregistered trademark rights under U.S. law. In its Notice of Opposition, the company alleges that it offered, sold and shipped clothing bearing the KAI mark to U.S. consumers through its e-commerce website. It further claims that the mark has acquired distinctiveness as an identifier of the source of its clothing.
These assertions raise an important evidentiary question: what constitutes sufficient use to establish enforceable trademark rights?
Evidence may include dated sales records, invoices, shipping documentation, product labels, website archives and marketing materials demonstrating how the mark was presented to consumers.
Importantly, the mere existence of a website accessible from the United States does not, by itself, establish qualifying U.S. trademark use. The nature of the commercial transactions and the mark's use in identifying the goods remain relevant.
The distinction between KAI and KAI COLLECTIVE is equally important. Kai Collective's pleaded case relies on alleged rights in KAI itself. The company must therefore demonstrate the relevant use and protection of that mark, rather than assume that operating under the longer corporate name automatically establishes identical rights in the shorter expression.
Identical Marks, Related Goods and Likelihood of Confusion
Priority alone does not resolve the opposition. Kai Collective must also establish the applicable grounds for refusing registration under Section 2(d) of the Lanham Act. The assessment of likelihood of confusion considers several factors, including the similarity of the marks, the relationship between the goods, trade channels and relevant consumers.
Here, the parties' applications concern the identical standard-character mark KAI. Their identified products also overlap substantially, particularly in relation to shirts, sweatshirts and other clothing. Kai Collective argues that consumers encountering clothing sold under KAI may mistakenly believe that the products originate from, are affiliated with or are endorsed by its business.
The fact that Kai Trump is a public figure does not automatically eliminate the possibility of confusion. Equally, the identity of the marks does not dispense with the need to consider the relevant legal factors. The central inquiry remains whether consumers are likely to be confused about the commercial source, sponsorship or affiliation of the goods.
Procedural Default and the Consequences of Failing to Respond
The October 1 Notice of Default introduces another important consideration. Under the applicable TTAB procedure and Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 55, an applicant's failure to answer an opposition may result in default proceedings and, ultimately, judgment against the applicant. However, entry of default is distinct from default judgment.
The TTAB's October 1 order did not determine that Kai Collective had established earlier trademark rights or proved likelihood of confusion. Instead, it provided KMT Ventures an opportunity to explain why judgment should not be entered following its apparent failure to answer. If default judgment is eventually entered, the opposition could be sustained without a full evidentiary determination of the competing trademark claims.
The case therefore illustrates how procedural compliance can materially affect the outcome of trademark proceedings, independently of the substantive arguments available to the parties.
Territoriality and the Protection of Fashion Brands Across Borders
The dispute also raises broader questions about international trademark protection. Trademark rights are generally territorial. A fashion company's establishment, commercial reputation or trademark registration in one jurisdiction does not automatically confer equivalent protection in another. For a business operating internationally, the relevant legal inquiry may involve the nature and timing of its commercial activities in each market, the existence of local registrations and the protection available to unregistered marks.
Kai Collective's reliance on alleged U.S. commercial use demonstrates why cross-border fashion businesses should not treat trademark protection as an issue to consider only after entering a foreign market.
This evidence shows that African fashion brands seeking international expansion must consider more than filing applications. They include conducting comprehensive trademark clearance searches, assessing unregistered rights, maintaining reliable evidence of commercial use and developing a registration strategy aligned with intended markets.
Conclusion
The dispute between Kai Collective and KMT Ventures demonstrates that trademark priority is not determined by filing dates alone. The nature of commercial use, the existence of earlier rights, the similarity of the marks and the relationship between the goods may all influence whether a trademark can proceed to registration.
At the same time, the procedural developments illustrate that the outcome of a trademark opposition may depend on compliance with filing and response requirements, not solely on the substantive strength of either party's claim. Until the TTAB issues a final determination, the competing claims remain unresolved on the record reviewed.
For fashion businesses, the broader lesson is the importance of approaching trademark protection as an ongoing commercial and legal consideration, particularly when building brands intended to operate across multiple jurisdictions.




Comments